The Response to Trump Should be One of Audacity, not Fear


I will not presume to put myself in the place of a Muslim, African American, or woman of color. That Donald Trump is now the president elect has sent a clear message to anybody not a native born white male. “You are not welcome in the United States.” Nevertheless, the Iranian American scholar Reza Aslan, who wrote a pretty good book on Jesus, not only has it wrong. The very last thing we need is more fear and more identity politics. His response is representative of a cynical liberal elite who hope to maintain their power in the aftermath of a catastrophic loss for which they have nobody to blame but themselves. While the Democratic Party may once again recapture the White House, they are no longer the party of John F. Kennedy and Franklin Roosevelt. They are finished as a progressive force in American history.

A close presidential election where a right-wing extremist beat an unpopular corporate Democrat? We’ve seen this movie before. In fact, it played very recently. In November of 2000, when George W. Bush narrowly edged out Al Gore for president, it was a disaster for the Democratic Party, and eventually for everybody in the United States, but it was also an opportunity. Only a year before, a small, but very militant American left had run the World Trade Organization out of Seattle. Americans had put the loathsome Bush/Cheney regime in the White House. They had also repudiated the equally loathsome Clinton/Gore regime that had given us NAFTA and the repeal of Glass-Steagall. The now discredited Democratic Party struck back furiously, not against the Republicans, but against Ralph Nader, transforming the once beloved consumer advocated into a political pariah, sending out a message to any potential successor. Attempt to organize outside the Democratic Party and we will destroy you.

The eventual outcome, eight years of George W. Bush followed by eight years of Barack Obama – essentially Al Gore with more charisma – was by no means a foregone conclusion. After Jim Jeffords, the Republican Senator from Vermont switched his party affiliation to “Independent” the Republicans lost control of the Senate. From January to September of 2001, George W. Bush was a laughing stock. There was every indication that he would be a one term president. We all know what happened next. The terrorist attacks of September 11 couldn’t have worked out better for the Bush/Cheney regime if they had planned it themselves. Suddenly the Republicans had exactly what they needed to ram their right-wing extremist agenda down our throat, fear. It was fear that gave us the Patriot Act. It was fear that let the NSA spy on us outside of the rule of law. It was fear that gave us the Bush-era torture/surveillance state, Gitmo, the Invasion of Iraq, and those massive tax cuts for the rich that destroyed whatever good had trickled down to the people from the tech bubble of the 1990s.

Through all of it, while the Democratic Party continued to behave disgracefully, the American people stood up and resisted. As Senator from New York, Hillary Clinton voted to support Bush on the invasion, and eventual destruction, of Iraq. On February 15, 2003, however, half a million people defied the Bloomberg administration to join the largest world-wide protest in history. The very next year, in the Summer of 2004, as many, or perhaps more, people came to New York to protest the Republican National Convention. It was a crowd so large that the NYPD needed to preemptively arrest and trump up charges on thousands of people in order to keep the demonstrations out of the corporate media. Fear, and yet another horrible, charisma impaired Democratic Party candidate allowed George W. Bush to win a second term as President, but his legacy was toast. His attempts to privatize Social Security failed. His pathetically inadequate response to Hurricane Katrina destroyed Karl Rove’s plan to bring more African Americans into the Republican Party. His intervention in the Terri Schiavo affair broke the rising power of the evangelicals he had funneled federal money to with his “faith based” initiatives and abstinence only sex education. The Iraqi Resistance did the rest. George W. Bush and Dick Cheney will forever be remembered as war criminals and incompetents.

Then what happened? How did we come full-circle right back to the year 2000? How did yet another right wing extremist in the form of Donald Trump beat yet another despised corporate Democrat in the form of Hillary Clinton in yet another close presidential election?

The problem was not a lack of resistance to George W. Bush. It was a lack of audacity. Democratic Party elites, who saw how well the Bush/Cheney regime had used fear, decided they could use it for themselves. Bush, they argued, was not just another Republican President. Rather, he was a break with history, a terrifying religious extremist who had preemptively invaded Iraq – an invasion the Democrats supported – legalized torture, and attempted to consolidate power in the “unitary executive.” The Democrats were right about George W. Bush. He was a terrifying religious extremist and dangerous would-be tyrant. Sadly, for the American people, the Democrats never lived up to their own word. We responded to their appeal. We gave the Democrats back the Senate and the House of Representatives in 2006. We gave them back the White House in 2008, and we waited for them to bring the Bush/Cheney war criminals to justice. They did just the opposite. No sooner did Nancy Pelosi become the very first woman Speaker of the House of Representatives then she declared impeachment to be “off the table.” No sooner did Barack Obama become the first African American President of the United State then he moved to to protect not only George W. Bush but everybody involved in the Bush torture/surveillance state. We’d been had. The Democrats had co-opted our resistance and delivered our country back into the hands of the corporations and the 1%.

Let’s not make the same mistake again. If Keith Ellison and Bernie Sanders want to break with the Democrats and start the long, painful process of building a genuine worker’s party, they should be welcomed with open arms. If they attempt to lead us down the same road the Democrats did from 2001 to 2008, they should simply be ignored. Now is not the time for fear, or for divide and conquer identity politics. The buffoonish Donald Trump is a combination of the wort parts of Ronald Reagan and Pat Buchanan. He has an agenda that combines tax cuts for the rich, savage cuts in public services for the working class, police repression and scapegoating for immigrants and the poor, but he will not act from a position of strength. Not only did he lose the popular vote to Hillary Clinton, his very presence in the White House depends on mobilizing fear and racism, upon rejecting the support of anybody not a native born white male. Donald Trump can and will be beaten. We can’t afford to make the same mistake we made during the Bush years. It’s time, at long last, to break with the Democratic Party, their cynical “dive and conquer” politics, and their neoliberal corporate agenda. What we need is not fear, but audacity.

“De l’audace, encore de l’audace,” the great French Revolutionary leader Georges Danton once said on the eve of an invasion by the reactionary powers of Europe, “toujours de l’audace et la Patrie sera sauvée.”


  1. i.jacksonsmith · · Reply

    I absolutely couldn’t agree more. I look forward to the future of the Democratic Party and I can’t wait to see what Sanders and Ellison will do. I also think you really chimed in on things that are often overlooked by both parties, that is – the influence of minor parties and also how the initial start of the war on terror played a huge role for the Republican party. Very nice analysis!

    1. I’m pretty sure my framing of Trump as the second coming of Bush (with an extra dollop of nativism and xenophobia) will play out. He won’t be a transformational figure but, rather, an acceleration of existing reactionary tendencies. I think what’s really scare now is that Paul Ryan will be put up on a pedestal by the corporate media as a “moderate” and be able to do whatever the fuck he wants.

  2. Kitchen Rants · · Reply

    I totally agree. Liberal Elites are done. Finito. They had their turn, they failed, not only failed, but took everyone down with them.

    1. Never underestimate the ability of the Clintons to slime their way back into public life.

      1. Kitchen Rants · · Reply

        I know. I read that and screamed “nooooo”.

  3. […] La reazione a Trump dovrebbe essere audacia, non paura […]

  4. Bawb Cawx · · Reply

    I think a real catastrophe was the inner-party dismissal of Bernie Sanders, the Democrats betrayed themselves with a force-fed “sure-thing” with Hilary, the Inner Echelons of Democrats did not see the Darkness of Hilary that led to her defeat. Bernie was a light, and I think he would have had an advantage on Trump, whereas both Hilary and Trump were just opportunists, full of negativity and their own personal blindness, with unattractive black spots in their pasts.

    1. A lot of the Trump vote was probably an “anybody but the Clintons” the same way as the vote for Christie was an “anybody but Jon Corzine” vote. But then you got Chris Christie as governor for 8 years.

  5. What you think about Cory Booker, seems like another opportunist, Cuomo as well ( will try to channel people’s legitimate rage , to corporate Democrats ).

    1. Bawb Cawx · · Reply

      Obama’s slogan was “Yes we Can!” Welllll, did he? Actually, Trump may have played the bad guy purposely, to get attention. Our old Steven Harper liked even bad news that put him “in the news”. Trump proves it true, lots of coverage created with outrageous behaviors the “press” (and critics) went GaGa over. George Thoroughgood “Bad to the bone” brought quick popularity just like Rolling Stones (Trump’s campaign song, Rolling Stones, “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”). Media hit parade suckers lots of “believers”. “I’m A Believer” made lots of Monkees.

      1. The one thing Trump, Obama and Hillary really seem to have in common was in seeing the Presidency as a prize, not as a means to do good. Obama wanted to be the first black President. he succeed, but didn’t do much more after that than act as a neoliberal corporate manager. Hillary wanted to be the first woman President, and she failed. What else did she want to do? Trump just wants to be President, to have the biggest job in the world to feed his big ego. Does he have any beliefs beyond that?

  6. Gilbert R · · Reply

    What you think about Cory Booker, seems like another opportunist, Cuomo as well ( will try to channel people’s legitimate rage , to corporate Democrats ).

    1. I can certainly do without Charter Schools Booker and his good buddy Chris Christie.

    2. This is an interesting video on Booker.

  7. Lots of people are not media savvy, fall for the tricks of the trade that the specialist “spinners” do for their customers. I was reading Marshall McLuhan at 16, Neil Postman had a great book, (Entertaining Ourselves to Death), and then there’s Noam Chomsky and Adbusters magazine that cut through the bafflegab of modern media – that really is out to “get” you, always with some new gimmick like Dogs for Shoes (or Phones) (Everybody loves a dog, or a cat, or a rainbow or a “family” showing those good ole “family values”). Negative values work, too, Hilary missed a big chance for sympathy votes when the press “revealed” her “weakness”. She could have milked that for sympathy, but instead tried to brush it off. A big brave face and a “carry on regardless” speech could have helped her.

    1. The main problem with the media (I think) is the very narrow spectrum of debate. 2016 was about a fascist vs. a right wing neoliberal. Neither of those ideologies conforms to what most of us want. So we just picked what we hated less.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: